---
title: Who Really Holds Financial Risk in Healthcare, Insurers or Providers?
description: Discover how financial risk in healthcare shifts from insurers to providers, revealing the true dynamics of self-funded plans and the impact on revenue cycle management.
image: https://insights.getixhealth.com/hubfs/Professional%20Desk%20Report%20with%20Blue%20Charts.png
---

[Skip to main content](https://insights.getixhealth.com/rcm-answers/who-really-holds-financial-risk-in-healthcare-insurers-or-providers#main-content)

[![Getix Health](https://insights.getixhealth.com/hs-fs/hubfs/raw_assets/public/GetixHealth%20Theme%20February2024%20%5BCLEANUP%5D/images/GetixHealth_Logo.png?width=184&height=298&name=GetixHealth_Logo.png "Getix Health")](https://insights.getixhealth.com/)

- [Solutions](https://getixhealth.com/solutions.html) 
    - [Patient Access](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/patient-access.html)
    - [Eligibility & Enrollment](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/eligibility.html)
    - [Workers’ Compensation](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/workers-compensation.html)
    - [Insurance Resolution](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/insurance-resolution.html)
    - [Medical Coding](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/chart-coding-audits.html)
    - [Early Out Self Pay](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/self-pay-patient-billing.html)
    - [Professional RCM Services](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/professional-rcm-services.html)
- [Insights](https://insights.getixhealth.com) 
    - [Company News](https://insights.getixhealth.com/company-news)
    - [Blog](https://insights.getixhealth.com/blog)
    - [Podcast](https://insights.getixhealth.com/podcast)
    - [RCM Answers](https://insights.getixhealth.com/rcm-answers)
- About 
    - [Our Company](https://getixhealth.com/about.html)
    - [Our Technology](https://getixhealth.com/technology.html)

[Let’s Talk](https://insights.getixhealth.com/rcm-answers/who-really-holds-financial-risk-in-healthcare-insurers-or-providers#gh_form_id)

[RCM Answers](https://insights.getixhealth.com/rcm-answers)

Answer

# Who Really Holds Financial Risk in Healthcare, Insurers or Providers?

Alex Oey· Updated November 6, 2026

[Podcast Episode 15View all episode content→](https://insights.getixhealth.com/?tag=podcast-episode-15)

Short answer

Discover how financial risk in healthcare shifts from insurers to providers, revealing the true dynamics of self-funded plans and the impact on revenue cycle management.

## Why It Matters

If you run revenue cycle, this distinction changes how you think about exposure after care is already on the books. When a high-cost claim is denied, delayed, underpaid, or hit with a clawback months later, the provider absorbs the shortfall. Care has been delivered and cannot be reversed. That means denial management, contract enforcement, and clawback defense are not administrative overhead. They are how a provider manages the risk that actually sits on its balance sheet.

## Key Takeaways

- About 70% of commercially insured patients are in self-funded employer plans, so the employer, not the insurer, holds the plan risk.
- About 1% of a self-funded employer group can account for roughly 33% of total cost, concentrating catastrophic exposure on the employer.
- Providers deliver care before reimbursement is confirmed, so denials, delays, underpayments, and clawbacks land as residual risk on the provider.
- Stop-loss and other protections do not eliminate provider exposure, especially when clawbacks arrive well after care has been delivered.
- Bad debt and charity have continued to rise year over year at Erlanger, which Chris connects to the broader strain in the financing model.
- Chris estimates the administrative side of healthcare sits somewhere between 25% and 35%, money that is not going to care.

## Expert Perspective

Chris Spady reframes the risk conversation directly. "I think we misunderstand risk in a really big way in this industry because we think through the fact that, hey, the insurer owns the risk there. And I just don't know that that's true anymore."

He points to how commercial coverage is actually structured. "70% of commercially insured patients is through a self-funded plan with their employer, so that employer owns that risk. And we know the statistics of, hey, 1% of your patients or 1% of the employer group that's in that self-funded group is going to account for about 33-ish percent of the cost."

Then he walks through what happens on the provider side. "What happens to those million-dollar claims? We know from our side that they get denied, they get delayed, they get underpaid. And so you can have stop loss and you can have protections that you feel like you have. But then when we just come back into nine days and there's just a tremendous clawback on the backside, I would say if I'm providing care and then trying to chase the money after it, we as the provider are really the ones that own the risk. And if who is next in line, it's the employer. So I would say the insurer is really just playing middleman here and doing very well at it."

In our editorial reading, that changes the operating question for RCM leaders. If the provider is the residual risk holder, then denial prevention, contract enforcement, and clawback defense function as risk management, not paperwork.

## Frequently Asked Questions

**If 70% of commercial lives are self-funded, what is the insurer's actual role?**   
In Chris's framing, the insurer in a self-funded arrangement is "really just playing middleman here and doing very well at it." The employer funds the claims and owns the plan risk. The insurer sits between the employer, the provider, and the patient without underwriting the primary exposure.

**Why do providers end up holding residual risk?**   
Because care is delivered before payment is settled. As Chris puts it, million-dollar claims "get denied, they get delayed, they get underpaid," and clawbacks can arrive after payment. Once care has been delivered, it cannot be reversed, so the financial exposure lands on the provider.

**Doesn't stop-loss coverage solve this for employers?**  
Chris notes that "you can have stop loss and you can have protections that you feel like you have," but he immediately points to clawbacks on the back side as evidence that these protections do not remove the exposure that flows to providers. Stop-loss changes how catastrophic claims are absorbed, but it does not resolve the residual risk providers carry after delivering care.

**What does this mean for how RCM teams should think about denials and clawbacks?**   
If the provider owns the residual risk, denial management, contract enforcement, and clawback defense are core to protecting the balance sheet. That reframing puts them on the same footing as any other risk management function, rather than treating them as back-office cleanup.

**How should providers think about employer conversations given this risk structure?**   
Chris raises the question of how much bad debt and plan-design information actually filters back to the employer. He is candid that a lot of it does not. Providers who can bring that data forward have a starting point for a shared accountability conversation with the employers whose plan designs shape what patients owe and what providers ultimately collect.

**Does this apply to Medicare and Medicaid populations?**   
The 70% self-funded dynamic is specific to commercial coverage. The broader point Chris makes, that providers deliver care first and then chase the money, applies across payer categories where denials, delays, and post-payment audits are in play.

## Bottom Line

In commercial coverage, the risk picture is not what it looks like on the surface. The employer holds the plan risk in most self-funded arrangements. The insurer often sits in the middle. The provider delivers care first and then tries to collect through a process where denials, delays, underpayments, and clawbacks are routine. That is where the residual risk in healthcare financing actually lives.

 

## Where to next?

[← Browse all answers](https://insights.getixhealth.com/rcm-answers)

[![Getix Health](https://insights.getixhealth.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/GetixHealth%20Theme%20February2024%20%5BCLEANUP%5D/images/GetixHealth_white.svg "Getix Health")](https://insights.getixhealth.com/)

 14141 Southwest Freeway Suite 300 Sugar Land, TX   
 United States, 77478

- [Solution](https://getixhealth.com/solutions.html) 
    - [Patient Access](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/patient-access.html)
    - [Insurance Resolution](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/insurance-resolution.html)
    - [Chart & Coding Audits](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/chart-coding-audits.html)
    - [Eligibility & Enrollment](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/eligibility.html)
    - [Self Pay Patient Billing](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/self-pay-patient-billing.html)
    - [Workers’ Compensation](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/workers-compensation.html)
    - [Professional RCM Services](https://getixhealth.com/solutions/professional-rcm-services.html)

- [Solutions](https://getixhealth.com/solutions.html)
- [Technology](https://getixhealth.com/technology.html)
- [Careers](https://getixhealth.com/careers.html)
- [Contact](https://getixhealth.com/contact.html)

- Learn 
    - [Blog](https://insights.getixhealth.com/blog)
    - [Podcast](https://insights.getixhealth.com/podcast)

### The core behind care.

 © 2026 GetixHealth. All Rights Reserved |[Privacy Policy](https://www.getixhealth.com/policy/Security_Privacy_Policy.pdf)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Alex Oey",
    "url" : "https://insights.getixhealth.com/rcm-answers/author/alex-oey"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-06T18:47:58.627Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-06T18:47:58.000Z",
  "headline" : "Who Really Holds Financial Risk in Healthcare, Insurers or Providers?",
  "image" : [ "https://insights.getixhealth.com/hubfs/Professional%20Desk%20Report%20with%20Blue%20Charts.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://insights.getixhealth.com/rcm-answers/who-really-holds-financial-risk-in-healthcare-insurers-or-providers",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://insights.getixhealth.com/hubfs/1.%20Official%20GetixHealth%20Logo%20_%20Full%20Color.png"
    },
    "name" : "GetixHealth"
  }
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Alex Oey"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-06T18:47:58Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-06T18:47:58Z",
  "description" : "Discover how financial risk in healthcare shifts from insurers to providers, revealing the true dynamics of self-funded plans and the impact on revenue cycle management.",
  "headline" : "Who Really Holds Financial Risk in Healthcare, Insurers or Providers?",
  "image" : "https://blog.getixhealth.com/hubfs/Professional%20Desk%20Report%20with%20Blue%20Charts.png",
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://insights.getixhealth.com/rcm-answers/who-really-holds-financial-risk-in-healthcare-insurers-or-providers",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://22082204.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/22082204/1.%20Official%20GetixHealth%20Logo%20_%20Full%20Color.png"
    },
    "name" : "GetixHealth"
  }
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "FAQPage",
  "mainEntity" : [ {
    "@type" : "Question",
    "acceptedAnswer" : {
      "@type" : "Answer",
      "text" : "Discover how financial risk in healthcare shifts from insurers to providers, revealing the true dynamics of self-funded plans and the impact on revenue cycle management."
    },
    "name" : "Who Really Holds Financial Risk in Healthcare, Insurers or Providers?"
  } ]
}
```